The next time you hear somebody mention college rankings when calling one college better than another, kick them in the shins.
Well okay, don’t be that harsh, but you should stop taking them seriously right there.
Somehow, college rankings have become a significant way to judge universities, yet few realize how difficult it is for one small number to fully and accurately summarize a university. Many use college rankings as a way to quickly compare two schools, yet few actually realize just how faulty rankings are:
#1: College rankings lists differ a lot.
The most commonly-cited list of college rankings is from the US News & World Report. This publication holds the most weight and is referred to more than any other, but there are still other ranking lists out there. Forbes has a list as well, and the Institute of Higher Education ranks schools as well. Each publisher uses an entirely different method to rank schools and emphasizes different factors.
The end result? A school ranked highly on one list might be terrible on another. UC Berkeley, for example, ranks 3rd overall on the Institute of Higher Education’s list, yet a modest 73rd on Forbes‘s list. The US News & World Report places Berkeley in the middle, at 21st. The University of Michigan ranks 26th from the Report, yet only 161st from Forbes. Keep reading »